Can you think of any other subject in which the teacher isn't really sure what they're teaching? Yoga teachers are faced with this daunting question every day! Is it meditation? Exercise? Enlightenment? Breathing? Gymnastics? It is relevant? Stolen? Distorted? Transformative?
(Photograph taken from the on-line article. Click it to link to the article.)
The New York Times has an article in their recent Sunday paper that gives a respectable overview of the challenges faced by the modern yoga community. Although the article focuses on John Friend, the founder of Anusara Yoga, the supporting text covers a variety of marginal but significant issues. Issues such as, in-fighting, materialism, cannibalization of tradition, intent and motivation. These are heavy issues in the yoga community and they seem to just get bigger every week.
::UPDATE::
John Friend responded on his blog page to the NYT article. You can read his response
here. Thanks to Ann for bringing it to my attention.
As a yoga teacher in the world today, and in our specific community, I have to ask myself every day what is yoga and what am I teaching. It is a curious position to be in but it keeps me honest.
Today my answer is this: Yoga is an integrated, systematic approach to well-being while in the human condition. As a teacher in our community, in our Park District, I can help you with the physical (strength, flexibility, breathing capacity) and mental (concentration, honest observation) aspects of that so you can be fully available for your own spiritual traditions.
We are a beautifully diverse community and our spiritual traditions run deep and wide. I unintentionally offended enough students in my early years of teaching that I have pared down the spiritual teachings to a minimum.
But we all have our physicality as a common denominator. We all have ribs, lungs, bones and muscles we need to propel and support us in our chosen activities. Yoga can teach us how to be physically integrated so everything else is easier. Yoga sees the body in a way no other practice or discipline does. It views the body in its entirety, working always as a whole.
On Being a Yoga Student
In the end, yoga is a practice. All becomes clear through practice. Practice a pose, a breath, a prayer. Practice on your own. Practice what you are taught and what you are not taught. Practice at the same time every day, or different times. Practice what you remember. Practice what you like. Practice what you don't like.
I'm doing all of that in the picture up there. I have never been taught that pose, but I like it so I do it. I have been taught enough to know how to be careful. I have been taught enough to know I am doing it wrong. I have been taught enough to know how not to injure myself trying. I am practicing in a familiar space at an unfamiliar time. I am practicing what I like. Then I did shoulder stand, which I don't like.
All the static in the yoga world becomes moot when you practice. You have to practice. Find a good class with a teacher who knows more than you do. Attend that class regularly, and maintain a consistent practice on your own.